RTIC 45 QT vs. YETI Tundra 45 Cooler: Comparison Review AC and Fans, July 18, 2025July 18, 2025 When it comes to investing in a high-performance cooler for camping, fishing, beach outings, or tailgates, two names often come up: RTIC and YETI. In this detailed comparison, we put the RTIC 45 QT Wheeled Ultra-Tough Cooler up against the YETI Tundra 45 Cooler to help you choose the right fit for your outdoor needs. RTIC 45 QT Wheeled Ultra-Tough Cooler The RTIC 45 QT Wheeled Ultra-Tough Cooler delivers impressive performance for anyone needing a reliable and rugged ice chest for outdoor adventures. With its rotomolded construction and thick insulation, it offers excellent ice retention—up to five days under proper conditions. During my testing at a weekend camping trip, the cooler kept our drinks and perishables perfectly cold, even in high heat. The retractable handle and large all-terrain wheels made transporting it across sand and rocky trails surprisingly easy, and the upright design fit well in tight car spaces. It’s definitely built for tough use, from fishing trips to backyard barbecues. That said, the cooler does have a few drawbacks. At 37 pounds empty, it’s quite heavy, so lifting it into a trunk or boat may require two people when fully loaded. Also, while it has a solid build and secure latches, it lacks a built-in drainage plug, which could’ve made cleanup more convenient. Still, if you’re after durability and long-lasting chill, the RTIC 45 QT is a strong value for the price. Key Features, Pros, and Cons Key Features 45-quart capacity (holds up to 60 cans) Up to 2.9″ of closed-cell foam insulation Rotomolded construction for maximum durability Rugged retractable handle and all-terrain wheels Freezer-style gasket for extended ice retention Pros Excellent ice retention (up to 5 days) Tough, impact-resistant build Easy to roll over sand and rough terrain Upright design saves storage space Includes built-in bottle opener/padlock shackle Cons Heavy at 37 lbs (empty) CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON YETI Tundra 45 Cooler The YETI Tundra 45 Cooler lives up to the brand’s reputation for premium performance and durability. During a three-day fishing trip, the Tundra 45 kept ice solid well beyond 48 hours, even in summer heat, thanks to its thick PermaFrost insulation and solid FatWall design. It comfortably held drinks, food, and bait with room to spare, and the included dry goods basket helped keep smaller items elevated and dry. The rotomolded construction felt rock-solid, and I had no concerns tossing it into the back of a truck. The T-Rex lid latches are a smart touch—sturdy and easy to grip even with wet hands. However, this cooler is not for everyone. Weighing in at 23 lbs empty, it’s noticeably heavy before adding any ice or contents. While it’s the ideal size for a weekend trip, it may be cumbersome for solo travelers or short outings. The price tag is also steep compared to similar-sized coolers, though the quality justifies the cost for frequent outdoor users. Overall, the Tundra 45 is a high-performance cooler designed for serious adventures—but with a weight and price that match. Key Features, Pros, and Cons Key Features Holds up to 26 cans (2:1 ice-to-contents ratio) Up to 3″ PermaFrost insulation Certified bear-resistant FatWall design Heavy-duty T-Rex rubber lid latches Includes one dry goods basket Pros Excellent multi-day ice retention Extremely rugged and durable Smart lid latch design prevents breakage Dry goods basket included Attractive color options Cons No wheels, making transport harder CHECK PRICE ON AMAZON RTIC 45 QT vs. YETI Tundra 45 Cooler: Comparison Review Both the RTIC 45 QT Wheeled Cooler and the YETI Tundra 45 are premium-grade hard coolers built for serious outdoor use, such as camping, fishing, beach trips, and barbecues. While they are similar in storage capacity and insulation performance, they differ in mobility, weight, price point, and overall design philosophy. Below, we break down the differences to highlight each cooler’s strengths and weaknesses. Key Specifications Comparison FeatureRTIC 45 QT Wheeled CoolerYETI Tundra 45 CoolerCapacity47 Quarts / ~60 cans45 Quarts / ~26 cans (2:1 ice ratio)InsulationUp to 2.9″ Closed-cell foamUp to 3″ PermaFrost foamWeight (Empty)37 lbs23 lbsWheelsYes (All-terrain)NoHandleRetractable tow handleStandard side handlesConstructionRotomoldedRotomoldedIncluded Accessories2 wheels, retractable handleDry goods basketBear-ResistantNo specific certificationYes (Certified)Price RangeMore affordableHigher-end / Premium pricing Ice Retention & Insulation Both coolers offer excellent ice retention thanks to their thick, high-density foam insulation. The YETI slightly edges ahead with its certified 3-inch PermaFrost™ insulation and FatWall™ design, allowing it to retain ice up to 4–5 days under typical use. The RTIC isn’t far behind, boasting 2.9 inches of closed-cell foam and similar retention time, especially when using RTIC’s cooling tips. However, YETI’s insulation quality and certification may appeal more to users going into extreme environments or remote locations where top-tier ice performance is crucial. Portability & Handling This is where the two products differ most significantly. The RTIC 45 QT has a major advantage: wheels. Its all-terrain wheels and retractable handle make it far more mobile—perfect for dragging across beaches, docks, or campsites. In contrast, the YETI Tundra 45 must be carried by hand using side handles. At 23 lbs empty (and much more when full), it can be awkward and heavy for a single person. For users who prioritize ease of transport, especially over uneven ground or long distances, RTIC’s design offers a clear advantage. Durability & Construction Both coolers are rotomolded, offering near-indestructible shells built to withstand drops, impacts, and rough handling. However, YETI’s bear-resistant certification and T-Rex heavy-duty rubber latches offer added peace of mind in wilderness scenarios. RTIC is similarly tough but lacks third-party certifications. If you’re camping in bear country or value rugged build quality backed by independent testing, YETI gets the edge here. Included Features RTIC includes wheels and a retractable handle, which are built into the product. YETI includes a dry goods basket, great for organizing snacks or keeping certain items dry. Both have smart design touches—RTIC has a 2-in-1 bottle opener/padlock shackle, while YETI’s latches are designed to be both durable and user-friendly. Final Verdict Choose the RTIC 45 QT Wheeled Cooler if you want: Easier transport with wheels and handle Great performance at a lower cost High capacity and long ice retention A practical option for family trips, barbecues, or the beach Choose the YETI Tundra 45 if you need: Certified bear-resistant construction Slightly better insulation and ice retention A trusted brand with premium build A more compact, clean design ideal for hunting or rugged expeditions FAQ What is the main difference between the RTIC 45 QT and YETI Tundra 45? The biggest difference lies in mobility and certification. The RTIC cooler includes built-in wheels and a retractable handle, making it easier to transport, while the YETI Tundra 45 offers certified bear-resistant construction and slightly better ice retention. How long can each cooler keep ice? Both coolers can retain ice for up to 4–5 days under proper conditions. The YETI Tundra 45 may hold a slight edge with its thicker 3-inch insulation and freezer-grade sealing gasket. Is the RTIC cooler too heavy to carry? Yes, the RTIC 45 QT weighs 37 lbs empty, and it can be challenging to lift when full. However, the built-in wheels and handle help offset that weight by making it easy to roll across most surfaces. Is the YETI Tundra 45 worth the higher price? That depends on your priorities. If you value certified durability, premium materials, and strong brand reputation, then the YETI may be worth the investment. If you’re looking for similar performance at a lower cost, RTIC may be the better choice. Can both coolers be locked? Yes. The YETI Tundra 45 has bear-resistant locking points, while the RTIC 45 QT features a 2-in-1 bottle opener that doubles as a padlock shackle, adding a layer of security. Enjoyed this review of RTIC 45 QT vs. YETI Tundra 45 Cooler? Then be sure to check out our other guides. Best 10,000 BTU Portable Air Conditioner Best 12000 BTU Portable Air Conditioner Best 12000 BTU Window Air Conditioner Best 10,000 BTU Window Air Conditioner Best Whole House Fan Best Portable Evaporative Swamp Cooler Best 18000 BTU Mini Split Best Battery-Powered Cooler Cooler cooler